Blog

Inspired Living!

The Etiquette of Talking Back

If you can say ‘I agree’ you should at least have grounds for doing so. To agree is just as much an exercise of critical judgement on your part as it is to disagree. You may as well be wrong in agreeing as in disagreeing. It was Adler Motimer who once said that ‘to agree without understanding is insane; to disagree without understanding is impudent.’ When you fully understand what is being said, it prepares the way for a candid evaluation of your response before your carry out your obligation of making an independent judgment. Any response not based on understanding is, for lack of a better vocabulary, primitive. It is equivalent to saying: ‘I don’t know what you mean, but I think you are wrong’. How could you possibly disagree with something you don’t even understand! What position would you be challenging in the first place?

Rule number two: All human disagreements can be resolved by eliminating both the misunderstanding and ignorance of the wider scope of issues at hand. All rational men (and that also includes women) can agree even if it’s agreeing not to agree. Man is a rational being. That rationality is actually the root source of his power to agree. However, the imperfections of this reasoning is the major cause of most of the disagreements that occur. Man is also a creature of passion and prejudice. The language he must use to communicate is an imperfect medium clouded by inadequately transparent thoughts, emotions and colored by selfish interests.

Rule number three: The purpose of every serious communication or conversation should be to try to convince, persuade or dissuade the other party. To be able to do that, you must develop rhetorical skills-learn how to convince or persuade; learn how to respond to anyone who tries to convince or persuade you. Please note that even when the parties disagree, each party’s line of persuasion should be respected. Hence the man who at any stage of a conversation, disagrees should at least hope to reach agreement in the end. He should be as much prepared to have his mind changed as he also seeks to change the mind of another. He should always bear in mind the possibility that he misunderstands or that he is ignorant to some degree.

Rule number four: You must never suppose that to criticize is always to disagree-a very popular but very unfortunate misconception. I long for the day when men and women of manners will dominate the television talk shows and after a debate proclaim; “You have convinced me that such and such is true”; “You have persuaded me that it is probable that…”; “Based on what you have said, I suspend my judgement”. Though not so obvious to most people, suspending judgement is also an act of criticism. It is taking the position that something has not been shown. It is saying that you are not convinced or persuaded one way or the other.

The media fraternity must therefore shoulder the responsibility of hosting debates or television talk shows with the hope and supposition that the programs aired will lead to the resolution of debate issues upon attainment of truth and reason in the light of all relevant evidence.

Kigwa Stephen is a re-known coach on public speaking skills & etiquette.

Image

Keeping you
Inspired &
Educated

Who's Online

We have 388 guests and no members online

Contacts

Tel: +254 724 259 794
Email: info@mskigwa.com 

Follow Me

Newsletter Subscription

Subscribe to Life Seminars Newsletter

Search